The new user interface is in preview!

Want to check it out? Click here! (If you don't like it, you can still switch back)

NOTE: As of the last sim, this league was under the minimum 20% capacity. Invite your friends to join MyFootballNow to keep this league alive! Then send them to this league to become the owner of a team! The league will expire at 1/09/2025 8:00 pm.

League Forums

Main - Suggestion Box

Play Scouting

By Ares
4/01/2017 5:59 pm
I've made this suggestion before, but I wanted to revisit it since I still think it'd be beneficial towards providing a minor debuff to the issue of restricted playbooks. I'd like to see the current 'scout 10 plays equally' feature changed. Users should be able to select as many (or as little) plays as they desire, and set a weight for each one. Every game sim teams will be allocated a number of 'prep points' for both offense and defense separately that will then be assigned in proportion to each play based off weight.

E.G.: You select three defensive plays, and weight them A: 10, B: 5, C: 5. If you are allotted say 100 prep points for defense, you would then assign 50 points to play A, 25 to B, and 25 to C. The more points allotted to any given play, the greater the bonus for your players when they play against it. The benefit to this is obvious: if a team only runs a handful of plays on either side of the ball, you'll gain a significant bonus because that's all you practiced against that week. If they run a diverse playbook you can choose to gain a smaller bonus but practice against a wide selection of plays, or maybe just target a handful to try and really stop. I think it adds an interesting element to the game, even beyond helping to address play overuse.

Re: Play Scouting

By parsh
4/01/2017 10:43 pm
I'm finding it funny Punisher liked this idea ... Lol .. j/k

Re: Play Scouting

By Bryson10
4/01/2017 10:50 pm
Ares wrote:
I've made this suggestion before, but I wanted to revisit it since I still think it'd be beneficial towards providing a minor debuff to the issue of restricted playbooks. I'd like to see the current 'scout 10 plays equally' feature changed. Users should be able to select as many (or as little) plays as they desire, and set a weight for each one. Every game sim teams will be allocated a number of 'prep points' for both offense and defense separately that will then be assigned in proportion to each play based off weight.

E.G.: You select three defensive plays, and weight them A: 10, B: 5, C: 5. If you are allotted say 100 prep points for defense, you would then assign 50 points to play A, 25 to B, and 25 to C. The more points allotted to any given play, the greater the bonus for your players when they play against it. The benefit to this is obvious: if a team only runs a handful of plays on either side of the ball, you'll gain a significant bonus because that's all you practiced against that week. If they run a diverse playbook you can choose to gain a smaller bonus but practice against a wide selection of plays, or maybe just target a handful to try and really stop. I think it adds an interesting element to the game, even beyond helping to address play overuse.


If i only had this for my last playoff game, :)

Re: Play Scouting

By punisher
4/02/2017 12:33 pm
parsh wrote:
I'm finding it funny Punisher liked this idea ... Lol .. j/k


thought we are suppose to be supportive of other people 's ideas especially if it makes the game better overall and where it evens up the playing field for all parties involved so thats why i liked this idea and i am sure i liked his other idea he posted before this one.

Re: Play Scouting

By Bryson10
4/02/2017 2:38 pm
i don't think it's about you supporting another's idea why he thought it was funny. It was basically the idea of the thread to combat owners that are limited playcallers. You are probably the poster boy for this type of playcalling so it's ironic if you think about it. :)

Re: Play Scouting

By parsh
4/02/2017 7:56 pm
Bryson10 wrote:
i don't think it's about you supporting another's idea why he thought it was funny. It was basically the idea of the thread to combat owners that are limited playcallers. You are probably the poster boy for this type of playcalling so it's ironic if you think about it. :)


Winner winner chicken dinner!!