I know we've weighed in on this before but here's my off the cuff list if i had to choose:



1. QB-Jonathan Demartini (Tennessee)
2. DT-Keith Thomas (Kansas)
3. QB-Don Anderson (Texas)
4. LB-Pepper Johnson (Ohio St.)
5. CB-David Orange (Alabama)
6. WR-Tony Jones (Notre Dame)
7. RB-Myles Gaskin (Washington)
8. CB-Julian Love (Notre Dame)
9. QB-Randy Williams (Oklahoma St.)
10. QB-James Sherwood (Navy)

Gaskin seems a bit high, same with Pepper... I think you forget how dominant Sherwood was in his prime, and Williams should def above the 2 of them.

Some darn good players in that list!

Pepper Johnson has been the most dominant defensive player the last 5 years? He's won many awards including Lombardi three years in a row? He's putting up db interception numbers. He's very underrated in my opinion and will go down as the leagues best LB. Gaskin may be slightly high due to his injury history but he's been the best RB our league has seen by a mile. Sherwood was very good but I think he came into the league a little late in his career to pile up the numbers to put him higher. It's tough to compare legends though so i totally get your point. I posted this for healthy debate though and i love hearing other owner's thoughts.

Go Bucks!!

Don't you mean Rutgers legend Keith Thomas and Rutgers legend James Sherwood??? ;)