Elite players that haven't played up to their abilities:

QB-Nicholas Smitherman (Georgia)
QB-Wesley Terry (Alabama)
WR-John Amaya (Marshall)
LT-Erik Wenzel (Ohio St)
LB-Harold Masters (Washington)
CB-Marcus Hyatt (Army)

I agree with Masters....

Don't know if I have the wrong system for him or what...Maybe he would have elite numbers if anyone ran the ball on a regular basis.

He had some nice tackle numbers the first year or two here, but nothing close to All-Pro

Maybe I try him on the outside?

Amaya has been a complete enigma.
Wasn't effective as a runner, not efficient as a pass catcher despite max stats.
I wonder if he's suffering from incompetent QB play or is he another high-stat player that is under-performing to his sliders. Howard would also fit in that category.

Another year means another chance for them to get it turned around; this is def NOT the list I want to have players on!

i think Hyatt took this list as a challenge! 4 picks in two games later, he's looking like All-American is calling his name

Shhh! lol